Content on this page requires a newer version of Adobe Flash Player.

Get Adobe Flash player

Work areas

Tyre vibrations

Sett-paved road (Place des Palais, Brussels). This type of road pavement is one of the noisiest, owing to its strong intrinsic megatexture.

When a tyre is rolling on an irregularity in a road surface and this irregularity has a horizontal dimension between about 1 cm and several tens of centimetres, vibrations are induced in the tread and the side walls of the tyre. This causes the tread and the side walls to radiate noise, like a drumhead. The greater the vertical dimension of the irregularity, the stronger the phenomenon. Tyre vibrations are generated most effectively when the road surface irregularity has the same horizontal dimension as the tyre-road contact area (which is about 8 cm for passenger cars). One of the most striking examples is the drumming noise of a car travelling on a sett-paved road.

It follows from this that a texture-optimized road surface must exhibit as few coarse irregularities (“megatexture”) as possible if noise emission from tyres is to be minimized.

Close
Air pumping

The small-sized coarse aggregate (between 2 and 4 mm) in the surface course of this two-layer porous asphalt surfacing forms an optimum fine macrotexture. This type of surfacing is also porous, which actually makes the fine macrotexture “redundant”. (DWW test section at Kloosterzande, Zeeland (the Netherlands))
The fine macrotexture of a surface course of a two-layer (non-porous) concrete pavement (N49 at Beveren (Belgium))

When a tyre is rolling on a very smooth road surface, air is compressed at the front of the tyre-road contact area and subsequently escapes noisily. At the rear of the contact area air is aspirated noisily. With cars travelling at a reasonable speed on an even road surface, this phenomenon can be observed as a hissing sound. This noise-generating mechanism can be suppressed by providing the road surface with a fine texture (irregularities with horizontal dimensions smaller than 1 cm, i.e., “fine macrotexture”) and/or by making the pavement porous. In the former case air is allowed to escape horizontally between irregularities before it is compressed. In the latter it can find its way out vertically through voids in the pavement.

Close
Horn effect

This phenomenon does not produce noise as such, but amplifies the noise generated by other mechanisms (e.g., tyre vibrations and air pumping). Noise can be reflected several times in the cone formed by the tyre tread and the road surface and, by this process, be amplified in one direction. This is similar to sound amplification in the conical part of a trumpet or a megaphone. The phenomenon can be suppressed by a sound-absorbing road pavement (porous) pavement. Under such conditions one half of the cone is stopped from reflecting noise.

Close
Road surface texture

The texture of a road surface can be described as the deviation of that surface from a perfect plane. Most important are the horizontal dimensions (the texture wavelength) of the bumps/hollows, as these will determine the effect of texture on noise production.

The greater the vertical dimension (the amplitude) of texture, the stronger the effect.

Texture with a short wavelength in relation to the length of the tyre-road contact area has a beneficial effect: by suppressing air pumping, such texture will abate tyre noise. Texture wavelengths ranging between 0.5 cm and 5 cm are referred to as macrotexture.

A finer macrotexture will benefit not only acoustic properties, but also the safety of road users, as it improves water drainage from the tyre-road contact surface – thereby preventing aquaplaning. This is particularly important at high speeds.

Texture with a longer wavelength (1 cm to a few tens of cm) has an adverse effect on tyre noise, as it causes the tyre to vibrate and radiate more noise. Texture wavelengths ranging between 5 cm and 50 cm are referred to as megatexture. It has been demonstrated that megatexture increases not only noise production, but also rolling resistance and, consequently, fuel consumption and CO2 emission. It should, therefore, be avoided as much as possible.

Texture with long to very long wavelengths (> 0.5 m) is called unevenness. It does not affect tyre noise, but may cause rattling of lorries and/or their cargoes. The amplitude of this long-wavelength texture must be restricted to secure the comfort of vehicle occupants, to avoid generating vibrations and to keep a low level of rolling resistance of the road surface.

Very fine texture, with wavelengths shorter than 0.5 mm, only plays a secondary part in noise production. However, this texture is important for safety, as it is one of the factors determining the skid resistance of the road surface. A too high microtexture causes excessive tyre wear.

Close
Absorption by the pavement

A road pavement can be given sound-absorbing properties by making it porous. This can be achieved by an appropriate choice of grading for the aggregates in the asphalt mixture. Conventional dense asphalt has a voids ratio of about 3 % and its voids are not interconnected or in contact with air. Porous asphalt (PA) has a voids ratio of about 25 %. The voids are interconnected and in contact with air. They are winding channels originating at the road surface and continuing down to the dense course under the porous course. Such a road pavement will absorb part of the incident sound energy (while converting it to heat) and reflect the other part. A dense pavement will reflect virtually 100 %.

To achieve effective sound absorption, the porous course of the pavement must be at least 4 cm thick and its voids ratio must be at least 20 %.

Porous road pavements abate noise in several ways, among other things by suppressing the horn effect.

A problem with porous pavements is that the voids tend to become clogged with dirt, especially on roads carrying calm (< about 90 km/h) and/or little traffic. This clogging rapidly deteriorates the acoustical quality of the pavement (leading to a loss in noise reduction of 1 dB(A)/year). Roads carrying faster traffic do not have this problem, as they can rely on a phenomenon called “self-cleaning effect”: in rainy weather car tyres force rain water through the voids, which are cleaned in the process. As a result, loss in noise reduction on motorways is only 0.3 – 0.4 dB(A)/year.

Another problem with porous pavements has to do with winter maintenance: when icy or covered with snow, they are less easy to clear – although this is not insurmountable, as demonstrated e.g. in the Netherlands, where porous asphalt (PA) is used systematically on trunk roads.

Close
Elasticity of the pavement
Experimental “poroelastic” road surfacing as developed in Japan, which is laid in mats of 1 x 1 m (DWW test section at Kloosterzande, Zeeland (the Netherlands))

A pavement with elastic properties in the same order of magnitude as the tyres themselves is extremely effective in preventing tyre vibrations. However, both asphalt and concrete are several orders of magnitude stiffer than car tyres, so that both types must be considered as “hard”. The difference in noise production between the two types of pavement cannot, therefore, be explained by their difference in stiffness. Experiments with rubber particles admixed to asphalt showed only small effects on tyre noise (typically 1 dBA). On the other hand, Japanese and Swedish experiments with poroelastic pavements composed of about 80 % of rubber granules from scrap tyres and about 20 % of polyurethane have shown that elasticity can play a major part in reducing tyre noise. Such pavements have not been used so far in Europe on account of their limited durability, but they are the subject of research (see e.g. the EU funded and BRRC lead European PERSUADE project).

Close
Low-noise pavements

A low-noise pavement can be defined as a pavement with at least one of the following three properties:

  • texture;
  • absorption;
  • elasticity,

optimized so as to reduce tyre noise.

Another definition sometimes used is: a type of pavement which reduces road traffic noise by at least 3 dB(A) with respect to a reference pavement (most often in dense asphalt concrete).

Examples of low-noise pavements (first definition) include:

  • porous asphalt (PA);
  • two-layer porous asphalt;
  • thin surface courses;
  • resin-bound (fine-graded) surface dressing;
  • fine-graded concrete;
  • porous concrete;
  • poroelastic pavements (still at the testing stage).
Close

Noise annoyance by road traffic – low-noise pavements

print

Description of the work area

Road traffic is one of the main sources of ambient noise. Controlling noise has been a priority to the European Union for a long time, resulting among other things in the publication of European Noise Directive 2002/49/EC. All member states are herein required to produce noise maps of the areas affected by major roads and in conurbations. This is to be followed by the drafting of action plans to abate noise in black spots, i.e. noisy areas which are densily populated.

Various sources contribute to the total noise generated by road traffic: engine noise, exhaust noise, fan noise, tyre noise, air turbulence, etc. The relative contribution of each source depends on a number of factors: type of vehicle (passenger car, lorry, etc.), vehicle condition (e.g. defective exhaust), speed, type of road pavement (sett paving, low-noise pavement), driving conditions (accelerating or constant speed), etc. Generally speaking, it can, however, be stated that tyre/road noise is an important source of noise. Tyre noise increases exponentially with the speed of the vehicle. For passenger cars tyre rolling noise is the dominant source at speeds as low as 30 to 40 km/h. For lorries tyre/road noise is predominant from about 60 to 80 km/h.

Rolling noise is the result of complex interaction between the tyres and the road surface. Various mechanisms contribute to the production of tyre noise. The most important are tyre vibrations, air pumping, and an amplification mechanism called «horn effect».

Besides the tyres themselves, the pavement plays a considerable part in generating/suppressing these phenomena. Three properties are essential in this respect: texture, absorptive capacity and elasticity.

Road pavements with one or more of these properties optimized will abate tyre noise and are referred to as low-noise pavements.

Low-noise pavements are a major tool in controlling road traffic noise, among other things because as a source-related measure they are often much (three to ten times) more cost-effective than propagation-related measures such as noise screens or facade insulation.

Equipment

Tests

Cooperation
Ongoing projects
Completed projects

Documents
Links
Training

Contacts:
Luc Goubert,
Anneleen Bergiers